Herkimer County Crime & Safety

Herkimer County, New York

Safety Score

38/100

Higher = safer

Safety Rating

High Crime

Total Crime Rate

1421.3

per 100K population

Crime Statistics

Violent Crime Rate

154.2

per 100K population

National avg 380.7

Property Crime Rate

1267.1

per 100K population

National avg 1954.4

Safety Score

38/100

Higher = safer

State avg 56/100

State Safety Rank

#46

of 60 counties (1 = safest)

Data Story

About Crime & Safety in Herkimer County, New York

Herkimer County Safer Than Most U.S. Areas

Herkimer County’s total crime rate of 1,421.3 per 100K is well below the national average of 2,385.5. The county maintains a safety score of 97.8, indicating a generally secure community. Eight local agencies provide consistent reporting to monitor public safety.

Trailing Slightly Behind State Safety Averages

The county's crime rate of 1,421.3 is higher than the New York state average of 1,074.4. This puts Herkimer’s safety score of 97.8 just below the statewide mark of 98.3. Local officials focus on bridging this gap through community-based policing initiatives.

Regional Comparisons Show Varied Safety

Herkimer County is more active than Greene County, which sits at a low 376.5 per 100K. However, it remains safer than the national average, showing a moderate crime profile for the region. It serves as a middle-ground county for safety in Central New York.

Property Crime is the Primary Issue

Property crime makes up the vast majority of local offenses at 1,267.1 per 100K residents. Violent crime is relatively low at 154.2 per 100K, though it is slightly higher than the state average of 125.0. Most law enforcement efforts are directed toward preventing theft and burglary.

Secure Your Property in Herkimer

Given that property crime is the main concern, high-quality locks and motion lighting are effective tools. Ensure that vehicles are locked and valuables are out of sight to deter theft. Staying vigilant helps lower these local rates and improves community safety.

SimpliSafe Home Security

Professional 24/7 monitoring for Herkimer County. No long-term contracts.

Get Protected →

ADT Security Systems

Trusted home security for Herkimer County residents since 1874.

Get a Quote →

Frequently Asked Questions

What is the crime rate in Herkimer County, NY?

Herkimer County has a total crime rate of 1421.3 per 100,000 residents, based on FBI Uniform Crime Reporting data. This includes both violent crimes (154.2 per 100K) and property crimes (1267.1 per 100K).

Is Herkimer County, NY safe?

Herkimer County has a safety score of 38/100, rated "High Crime". A higher safety score indicates lower crime rates relative to other counties nationwide. It ranks #46 out of 60 counties in New York for safety (1 = safest).

How does Herkimer County crime compare to the New York average?

What types of crime are most common in Herkimer County?

How is crime data measured and reported for Herkimer County?

Crime data for Herkimer County comes from the FBI Uniform Crime Reporting (UCR) program. Local law enforcement agencies submit data on violent crimes (murder, rape, robbery, aggravated assault) and property crimes (burglary, larceny-theft, motor vehicle theft) to the FBI. Rates are calculated per 100,000 residents to allow fair comparison between counties of different sizes. The safety score (0-100) is derived from these rates, with higher scores indicating safer counties.

What is being done about crime in Herkimer County?

Herkimer County has a safety score of 38/100, which is below the New York average of 56/100. Many counties with above-average crime rates invest in community policing, crime prevention programs, neighborhood watch initiatives, and social services aimed at reducing crime over time.